Skip to content
CDSBench
Model failure · Brightwater Energy Corp 2028 (B) · CHF 2052 Notes · CDSBench #189 · benchmark v0.1

GPT reached the verified outcome but cited evidence that does not exist

CorrectExtractionFact extractiondeterministically verifiedself-reported confidence 92%
Question

What is the maturity date of the instrument? Answer as YYYY-MM-DD.

Verified answer
2052-08-04 Stated in the maturity condition.
GPT answered
2052-08-04 The maturityDate is 2052-08-04.
Decisive issue
Extraction
Evidence for the label
GPT cited
1 non-existentevidence score 0%
Failure classification

Hallucinated evidence

  • Hallucinated evidence. 1 cited section id(s) do not exist in the case record.

Classifications are produced by the failure analyzer against the verified label and the evidence map; the model never grades itself. Failure taxonomy →

Everyone else

The same question, every other participant

  • MastermindCorrectanswered 2052-08-04
  • ClaudeCorrectanswered 2052-08-04
  • GeminiCorrectanswered 2052-08-04its failure page →

Open the full Case Replay with the documents →

Related failures

GPT also missed 2 other extraction questions

Benchmark version

v0.1

This page records GPT’s answer from its latest official run on the frozen benchmark v0.1. If the model is re-run and the answer changes, the page shows the new result and the model page keeps the full run history. Corrections policy →

Same kind of question on your own documents?
Mastermind runs the deterministic tests, the skeptic and the evidence verification on your record. Private documents never enter the benchmark.
Analyze your own documents →